Ryujinx, Dolphin, Mupen64, Cemu, Visual Boy Advance, BizHawk, RetroArch, Snes9x, Mesen, and others are emulators of Nintendo consoles that have not been taken down by Nintendo.
There are some important rules to follow if you want to make an emulator. Yuzu made some big mistakes. It’s legal to build an emulator. It’s not legal to profit from encouraging from piracy, or circumventing DRM which is what Yuzu did.
any switch emulator, and dolphin have to circumvent drm or encryption to work. dolphin literally includes the decryption keys yet nintendo hasnt tried to take them down, only when they warned valve about it. so they’re all doing something illegal
Dolphin has a defense. There is a reverse engineering exemption to the DMCA that Dolphin is likely protected by. Dolphin’s use of the keys might be entirely legal. If this went to court there’s a reasonable chance Dolphin could win. It wouldn’t be a clear-cut case at best.
The other thing protecting Dolphin is the fact Dolphin does not make money. They do not solicit donations publicly. Nintendo doesn’t have easily citable patreon numbers to add to the damages, nor would Dolphin have the means to pay nintendo even if they won.
Taking Dolphin to court is a bad idea for nintendo. All risk, no reward. Keeps Dolphin safe unless one of those things changes, like putting it on steam.
It’s also possible that Yuzu just didn’t want to fight a legal battle which is expensive and very stressful. Chance of winning also obviously factor into that, but I don’t see why it has to be the main reason.
Ryujinx, Dolphin, Mupen64, Cemu, Visual Boy Advance, BizHawk, RetroArch, Snes9x, Mesen, and others are emulators of Nintendo consoles that have not been taken down by Nintendo.
There are some important rules to follow if you want to make an emulator. Yuzu made some big mistakes. It’s legal to build an emulator. It’s not legal to profit from encouraging from piracy, or circumventing DRM which is what Yuzu did.
any switch emulator, and dolphin have to circumvent drm or encryption to work. dolphin literally includes the decryption keys yet nintendo hasnt tried to take them down, only when they warned valve about it. so they’re all doing something illegal
And yet the project still is up.
Dolphin has a defense. There is a reverse engineering exemption to the DMCA that Dolphin is likely protected by. Dolphin’s use of the keys might be entirely legal. If this went to court there’s a reasonable chance Dolphin could win. It wouldn’t be a clear-cut case at best.
The other thing protecting Dolphin is the fact Dolphin does not make money. They do not solicit donations publicly. Nintendo doesn’t have easily citable patreon numbers to add to the damages, nor would Dolphin have the means to pay nintendo even if they won.
Taking Dolphin to court is a bad idea for nintendo. All risk, no reward. Keeps Dolphin safe unless one of those things changes, like putting it on steam.
It hasn’t been determined by a court whether or not yuzu did anything wrong, they settled out of court.
They settled because they knew what would happen if it went to a court. Yuzu’s actions were blatantly illegal.
It’s also possible that Yuzu just didn’t want to fight a legal battle which is expensive and very stressful. Chance of winning also obviously factor into that, but I don’t see why it has to be the main reason.